CORPORATE vs INDIVIDUAL TRUSTEE

Barring a few exceptions, it can be the members individually or alternatively can be a company with the members as the directors and shareholders of the company. The choice, either way, is that the trustee of an SMSF can be either individual trustees or a company as a trustee.

When choosing the appropriate trustee structure for your SMSF, a closer examination of the advantages and disadvantages will assist you in determining what is right for your needs.

Looking at the cost, a company as a trustee could cost around $1,000 or more to establish initially. An annual fee of roughly $50 will also need to be paid to ASIC, and when you are finished with the company, there will also be costs associated with deregistering it. Using individual trustees, there is no initial cost associated.

But price is about where it ends in terms of the advantages of using individuals over companies as trustees. While price-wise, it may seem advantageous at first glance, companies as trustees possess more benefits over individual trustees.

First, and most importantly, you have asset separation. The assets are held in the name of a separate entity and if the individuals are ever attacked financially there is nothing to point towards the super fund.  Even though the assets of the fund should be protected even with individual trustees, if assets are in the individual names you will need to spend legal fees to prove they are fund assets.
If the members of the fund are changed, you will need to change the trustees, and if you change the trustees, you need to change the ownership of all the assets. This will be a major administrative burden, as a lawyer will need to be engaged to do the necessary documentation to change the trustees, and is required to be engaged if real estate is involved. In most instances, simply changing trustees and ownership of the assets will end up costing far more in the long run than the initial investment costs of setting up a corporate trustee.

People always make mistakes, but with SMSFs, mistakes can create breaches of the law. If you have all of the assets in a special purpose company name, there is less chance that you will make the mistake of thinking that a particular fund asset (such as a bank account) will be your own asset. If you take money from the super fund account by mistake, thinking that it is your own money, the auditor may report a breach. If you deposit money into your SMSF account, which is actually yours and not the fund’s, you may not be able to take that money back out if the mistake isn’t realised in time.

Do you already own a company, and after reading this article, are asking yourself if you can use that to set up a corporate trustee? It is only recommended that you do so if the company is not operating in any other capacity but yes, doing so can save on the initial set-up costs.

There is no one size fits all advice we can give you, but we can try to determine what would best suit your needs. We may sit down with you and agree that individual trustees may be appropriate, but if our recommendation is for a corporate trustee, it is for sound financial reasoning.